Wooks's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[What Are We Fighting For]

i like the feeling

I like the feel of the movie, the blur and all the special effects did a lot to it, and i thought it was great

what i didn't like:
1. you allready heard it, but your animations do suck, look at real life material and try to do it in 3D exactly the same
2. the models of the people are allmost the standard bi-peds from max, i'm sure you altered them, but it's still way to obvious
3. i liked your camera poses, but you really messed it up with the plane at the end

still, i think you did a great job, and to answer your question 'what are we fighting for?' probably oil i guess

raven9892002 responds:

thanks for taking the time to watch and give your feedback

1. yes i already heard that my animations suck and this is something that i am going to focus on improving next time round, probably by using, as you said, real life reference material.
2. your right, the characters are pretty much the standard max biped with a helmet stuck on their head and given a black material, but i feel this helps give the feeling that these are just average people stuck into a horrible situation, so i stick by my choice, however my next animation will probably need more detailed characters so the chances are this is the last time you will see them from me
3. and the angles used in the plane part, yea i really did screw up there and it almost ruins the whole thing, but i just wanted to get this done before i move to Austria so i just had to throw something together to throw on the end there and i just didn't give it the attention it deserved.

and your probably right about fighting for oil there

[Madness Neurosis Collab 3]

not bad

at first i found it sucked badly, but then i saw how old you all are, and i think there is a future for you guys. keep practicing, you're on the right way

here's why i thought it sucked:
1. crappy animation: really learn to animate boys, half the shit doesn't even look realistic, look closer at the real madness movies to see how it's done properly
2. Bad navigation: the main menu is ok, but the rest is crap, i mean, you're movie ends and all it says is "menu", come on, and then on the comics, once you got to the end, you had to click all the way back, thats just bloody annoying
3. it took to long to load, i'm sure you you could compress a whole lot of this. for example the song!

What i liked:
1. the preloader was cool
2. some of the movies had some original elemens and looked cool
3. it's MADNESS!!

LittleLuckyLink responds:

How the fuck do you expect it to end?
A little lobster dinner?

[PTFA Guy Short 7]

nice work

I liked it, especially the beginning, i was really excited what they were going to type, and then he falls asleep and gets older, hilarious. I really liked it and i would probably like it more if it was a bit faster, no offence, but at somepoint i found it boring

Ryan-Smith responds:

I understand, I can never get timing quite right, sometimes its too fast for people and sometimes too slow. I'm working on fixin that.

[Penguin Pandamonium]

Could be more

i liked the beginning and the egg that started to roll, but why does it end right there, it would be funnier if the egg just splatted open, anything is funnier then this ending, and put a start, stop and a replay on your movie

i see some talent here

adZ2222 responds:

Sorry about the length, I wish I could have done more aswell, however it was a college project for me and I only had 5 hours, and for my first time animating by using layers on photoshop I was understandly slow :P I'll be using flash for my future animations and I hope you see, rate and review them. Thanks.